BimmerFile Review: 2011 128i

2011 BMW 128i

So what does BMW have to offer the driver who ‘s interest lies not in outright pace, road-holding, or the satisfaction of a perfectly executed heel-toe downshift, but one who requires simply a well balanced car to handle the daily grind.This is a different flavor than what we typically get excited about at BimmerFile, we make no secret our preference for the sporting inclined offerings from BMW.However, I ‘ve recently spent the past week getting to know the slower side of BMW, a more relaxed proposition in what is likely the most common 1-series, the automatic equipped 128i.

2011 BMW 128i

What ‘s on offer is a 2011 Space Gray Metallic Steptronic equipped 128i with the Premium and Cold Weather packages.The content is almost completely not what I would ever choose, and in that way I really had to alter my perspective, in that what we have here is certain to be the “business case ” 128i.The car most buyers shopping in this size & price point at a BMW dealer are likely to find and drive away with, in part because it ‘s also what ‘s most likely to be spec ‘ed and held on dealer lots.There are more than enough Lexus ‘ sales to give evidence that not all buyers are interested in the intensely focused drivers cars we crave at BimmerFile.So let ‘s try to look at this honestly.

The 128i features the N52 3 Liter engine tuned in the American market to output 230 hp and 200 lb/ft of torque while achieving 28 mpg highway.It revs sweetly to redline providing more than enough power for the daily grind and, if mated to a 6-speed manual, likely plenty rewarding on the track.The well known Steptronic proved itself a competent companion to the motor, plodding along I never really felt held back by it.However, the moment quickly passed and I was “shifting ” soon enough.Lacking the tactile intimacy of a proper clutch and the immediate response of a DCT, I was able to achieve a level of control I was more comfortable with, if not completely satisfied.If the traditional torque-converter automatics will see their demise with the onset of DCT style transmissions, then it ‘s a shift that couldn ‘t happen soon enough.

Initial road disruptions transmitted by the fitted 17 ” wheels on all-season run-flat tires were still not on the level of a more traditional set-up.Although an improvement over earlier efforts, it continues to validate the long held complaint by many that the tire manufacturers just haven ‘t delivered the ride quality expected.Grip was as expected, easily overcome by the competent chassis (lots of throttle, manual mode, DTC off).The suspension was well balanced, if softer with more roll, dive & squat than I ‘d prefer, although probably perfect for the target demographic.Certainly hints of a very competent chassis that will shine when more stiffly sprung and mated to a more substantial power-unit.The steering was nicely weighted and plenty communicative.Pretty standard BMW stuff, no surprises here.

As for the interior appointments, well, I ‘d always believed iDrive and NAV was unnecessary.Brilliant, but unnecessary.Particularly with the progression in smartphone technology, the multi-media, automobile interface I ‘ve always regarded a tool for the directionally impaired, for the traveling salesman that can ‘t find his socks let-alone his way through the countryside.Certainly the iDrive offers a window into the car and a level of interaction and customization unattainable otherwise, but I never missed it in my non-iDrive equipped cars.Until I tried to use my iPhone through the standard radio display.Sure, it functions well, and is as intuitive to use as can be expected given the limitations of the medium, but ease-of-use compared to iDrive is no comparison.The standard radio display acquits itself admirably to the task, displaying track and title information, and functionality is easily grasped; however when paired to an 80 gb iPod classic, scrolling through artists and track selection can take a while with a lot of time furtively glancing between the radio and the road.I can ‘t say definitively that I ‘d spec iDrive on my new BMW, but I ‘d look hard at the options list and my lifestyle priorities before passing, otherwise I ‘d make liberal use of playlists to facilitate easier operation.

The rest of the car is standard BMW fare, good build quality and quality of materials.My car was equipped with leather seating surfaces which leaves the balance of the seats in BMW ‘s excellent leatherette.The color and texture are very very close, but a close examination reveals a slight difference, one wonders how these materials will compare after 60,000 miles of the daily grind.

Which brings me to my single largest complaint of the car, the seats, they ‘re abysmal.No, they ‘re not medieval in their design, nor are they poorly built of shoddy materials, they ‘re just poorly designed.These are not the excellent available sport seats.There ‘s no lateral support to be had, cushion or seat-back, both completely lacked sufficient bolstering, even for the relatively low limits afforded by the tires and softer suspension.Even a friend who ‘s relatively indifferent to things automotive commented on how poorly seated she felt.Perhaps we as Americans are simply too fat to fit in anything else that the excellent sport seats can ‘t be spec ‘d as standard, they are far and away more comfortable, offer more support and are absolutely a better driving proposition.

Okay, so maybe I wasn ‘t as objective as I ‘d hoped to be, but don ‘t get me wrong, I actually do like the carand understand where it belongs in the BMW portfolio.For the average car buyer looking for a balanced approach to the daily grind the 128i as equipped is nearly perfect.It ‘s the enthusiast within that recognizes the excellent chassis and motor are being let down by a soft suspension and automatic transmission.Perhaps, if you need a 1-series at this price-point a 128i M-sport would be the way to go.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • Greenkirby21

    the 128i WITH sport package fixes most of the problems! I don’t like the 128i without it!

  • Tom

    I think the last paragraph hits the nail on the head. I guess I agree because I drive a 125i M-Sport with manual transmission, and think that’s a pretty near ideal combination. More than adequate power, really supportive seats, great steering wheel, great suspension setup, 18″ wheels, and a more aggressive look in front. My commutes to and from work are the best part of the day.

    Matt is right about the combination he tried was what you’d find on the dealer’s floor – mine was on special order.

  • chas58

    Yeah, one or three series, this is what you will find on the lot.

    However the 1 with the sports pack and manual transmission is near ideal. yeah, more power is always fun, but for street driving, I find 230HP in a naturally aspirated engine more fun to play with (although it does need an exhaust with more personality).

  • goat

    Good review and agree with all points. Timely too, as I’ve been test driving 128’s and 328’s very recently too and can offer my take…

    Here is how you fix today’s 1 and 3 series bimmers (assuming you are a driving enthusiast): – order Sport Suspenson; – order Sport Seats; – order M-steering wheel and Shift Knob; – DO NOT order the autotragic transmission (at least until they offer DCT with the 3.0L NA motor).

    Fixed. 🙂 Fantastic balanced and comfortable driver’s car, great shifter, decent steering feel (ratio is quick, but the 128i could use more weighting), highly rewarding in the twisties, enough HP to make it very quick point-to-point, and with a lovely and willing engine note from 5K-7K that rewards trips up the tach.

    (It does mean likely having to order a car though, as most on the lot won’t have Sport Pack and if they do are most likely fitted with the automatic transmission.)

  • I still think that a 128i in base form done up with BMW Performance parts, suspension, exhaust, shifter and steering wheel would be a real hoot as a DD…. with a fairly reasonable price point and fuel economy.

    I like the N52 a great deal, wish we had the DI N53 but that is another tale entirely.


  • Bob

    I just traded a Z4M coupe for a 2010, 128i 6 sp manual, sport and don’t miss the old car a bit. Of course the 128i doesn’t have the power, but it is a very balanced car with excellent suspension. The extra room is important to me.

  • Pingback: BimmerFile » Archive » BimmerFile’s Best of 2010()

  • Rob

    A fair review. I just picked up a 2009 128i steptronic but was sure to pick one up with the Sport package/xenon/leather, to address the concerns above about seats and suspension, both of which are strongly remedied with the ZSP. I think the car is perfect in this state. I’m ok with the automatic, it’s all i need for my daily errand running. For the track I’ve got my E86 Z4M 6MT, and for weekends the E60 SMG III, so i’ve got one of each type you could say!